We are proud to offer only the finest certified vintage and second-hand fashion accessories from the world's most exclusive fashion houses. All products meet our strict standard of excellence.
We make luxury accessible for all. We are proud to offer only the finest certified vintage and second-hand fashion accessories from the world's most exclusive fashion houses. All products meet our strict standard of excellence.We make luxury accessible for all. We are proud to offer only the finest certified vintage and second-hand fashion accessories from the world's most exclusive fashion houses. All products meet our strict standard of excellence.
The authenticity of this piece of jewelry has been checked and certified by Kathrine, who has 20 years of experience in vintage and luxury jewelry.
Minor marks on hardware
See more details
/ Tiffany & Co
/ Jewelry
/ Earrings
Verified authenticity by our experts
read more
Free shipping & duty to EU, UK & NO
14-day money-back guarantee
Read more about our authenticity process
Sell your vintage bags, watches, jewelry and accessories
Give your luxury vintage item a second life. Contribute to a more sustainable fashion world by selling your beloved product to us. It’s fast, secure, and available for sellers within the EU.
Product Description
Perfect for date nights, weddings or a polished office look, these vintage Tiffany & Co. sterling-silver heart studs lend subtle sparkle and timeless romance. With iconic Return to Tiffany engraving, they transition effortlessly from day to evening and make a cherished gift for anniversaries or birthdays.
RETURNS
A Retro Tale offers 14 days return policy upon receipt of your order.
In order to request a return, please email [email protected] with your order number and state ”return request” in your email. From there, our Customer Support will confirm that your return request has been approved and further instructions will be provided by email.
Please note that the return shipping fee is covered by the returnee and all return shippings to A Retro Tale must be traceable. Thus, please retain your receipt of shipping and tracking number until your return has been completed and you have received your refund.
Please allow up to 10 business days for your return to be completed from the return shipping date as shipping time might vary depending on shipping country and shipping provider.
Bags
Watches
Jewelry & Accessories
Sell your vintage bags, watches, jewelry and accessories
Give your luxury vintage item a second life. Contribute to a more sustainable fashion world by selling your beloved product to us. It’s fast, secure, and available for sellers within the EU. You receive your payment right after you accept our final quote.
IN STORE
/
IN STORE
• Sterling silver
• Heart-shaped design
• 'Return to Tiffany' engraving
• Post back closure
• Vintage
Show more product information
Q: What size are they? A: Approximately 1.5 cm high × 1.9 cm wide × 0.1 cm deep (about 15 × 19 × 1 mm). Measurements are taken at the widest points; please refer to the Measurements on this page for exact sizing.
Q: Do hallmarks and proportions vary between authentic pairs? A: Yes. Genuine Return to Tiffany heart studs have changed slightly over the years and exist in different sizes. Authentic pieces typically carry crisp Tiffany & Co. and 925 marks; minor differences in placement or font can occur by production year and size.
Please note that the majority of our items are vintage and therefore have tales to tell unless stated otherwise. Therefore, please look at pictures, descriptions and measurements provided as they give you the best idea of the story this item has to tell.
* Please note that when you buy a vintage product, the dimensions may vary slightly from a new one depending on previous care and storage.
Measurements & Capacity
SHIPPING
All orders are insured and trackable. Once your shipment has been issued, a link to our Track & Trace service will be provided where you can track your shipment and check delivery status online.
A Retro Tale offers free shipping to most EU countries. Click here to see the full list of eligible countries.
Outside EU, Åland and UK: Please note that customers outside of EU, Åland and UK are responsible upon delivery for any import duties, goods and services tax (GST), value added tax (VAT), customs fees, and any other tax on top of the A Retro Tale listed price. Delivery delays may occur due to external factors such as customs clearance, holidays etc.
We offer secure shipping via DHL and UPS with the following delivery time:
Europe: 1-4 business days.
Outside Europe: 3-6 business days.
Delivery & Returns
Q: What are these earrings made of? A: They are crafted in solid 925 sterling silver with the collection’s signature Return to Tiffany heart motif and engraved inscription.
Q: What does the Return to Tiffany inscription mean? A: The phrase traces back to a Tiffany key ring introduced in the late 1960s that was engraved with “Please Return to Tiffany & Co. New York.” The wording became an emblem of the collection and appears on many heart designs, including these studs.
Q: Are they suitable for sensitive ears? A: Sterling silver (925) is widely tolerated, but it is an alloy and very sensitive wearers can occasionally react to trace metals. If you have a known nickel allergy or highly sensitive skin, we recommend a short test-wear and avoiding perfumes or lotions on the posts.
Q: What size are they? A: Approximately 1.5 cm high × 1.9 cm wide × 0.1 cm deep (about 15 × 19 × 1 mm). Measurements are taken at the widest points; please refer to the Measurements on this page for exact sizing.
Q: How do they fasten, and do they come with backs? A: They have sterling silver posts with friction (butterfly) backs for pierced ears. The pair includes backs; any additional items, such as a branded box, are listed under Accessories for this listing.
Q: Are they heavy to wear? A: No. As polished sterling silver studs with a slim profile, they are designed for comfortable, everyday wear. Comfort can vary by ear shape, but most customers find them light on the lobe.
Q: How should I clean and care for them? A: Gently polish with a non‑abrasive silver cloth and, if needed, use a small amount of silver jewellery cleaner. Rinse in warm water, dry thoroughly, and store in an anti‑tarnish pouch. Avoid chlorine, saltwater, harsh chemicals, or abrasive cleaners to minimise tarnish and preserve the finish.
Q: Can I wear them in the shower, swimming, or to sleep? A: We recommend removing sterling silver earrings before bathing, swimming, exercising, or sleeping to prevent accelerated tarnishing and to avoid bending the posts.
Q: Do hallmarks and proportions vary between authentic pairs? A: Yes. Genuine Return to Tiffany heart studs have changed slightly over the years and exist in different sizes. Authentic pieces typically carry crisp Tiffany & Co. and 925 marks; minor differences in placement or font can occur by production year and size.
Q: How does A Retro Tale authenticate this item? A: Every item is vetted by our in‑house experts using multi‑point checks of materials, finish, engraving, hallmarks, construction, and overall craftsmanship. We stand behind the authenticity of all items we sell and are happy to share additional photos or details on request.
FAQ
Trustpilot
If you have any questions about customs, duties, or taxes, feel free to contact our customer service team — we’re happy to help!
ADD TO CART
Delivered with
box
Made in
Italy
Product number:
859-35397
Tiffany & Co Return to Love Heart Earrings
RETURNS
A Retro Tale offers 14 days return policy upon receipt of your order.
In order to request a return, please email [email protected] with your order number and state ”return request” in your email. From there, our Customer Support will confirm that your return request has been approved and further instructions will be provided by email.
Please note that the return shipping fee is covered by the returnee and all return shippings to A Retro Tale must be traceable. Thus, please retain your receipt of shipping and tracking number until your return has been completed and you have received your refund.
Please allow up to 10 business days for your return to be completed from the return shipping date as shipping time might vary depending on shipping country and shipping provider.
Show all images
302 €
START SELLING
Bags
Watches
Jewelry & Accessories
Home
Very Good Condition
Perfect for date nights, weddings or a polished office look, these vintage Tiffany & Co. sterling-silver heart studs lend subtle sparkle and timeless romance. With iconic Return to Tiffany engraving, they transition effortlessly from day to evening and make a cherished gift for anniversaries or birthdays.
Please note that the majority of our items are vintage and therefore have tales to tell unless stated otherwise. Therefore, please look at pictures, descriptions and measurements provided as they give you the best idea of the story this item has to tell.
* Please note that when you buy a vintage product, the dimensions may vary slightly from a new one depending on previous care and storage.
Q: What are these earrings made of? A: They are crafted in solid 925 sterling silver with the collection’s signature Return to Tiffany heart motif and engraved inscription.
Q: What does the Return to Tiffany inscription mean? A: The phrase traces back to a Tiffany key ring introduced in the late 1960s that was engraved with “Please Return to Tiffany & Co. New York.” The wording became an emblem of the collection and appears on many heart designs, including these studs.
Q: Are they suitable for sensitive ears? A: Sterling silver (925) is widely tolerated, but it is an alloy and very sensitive wearers can occasionally react to trace metals. If you have a known nickel allergy or highly sensitive skin, we recommend a short test-wear and avoiding perfumes or lotions on the posts.
Q: What size are they? A: Approximately 1.5 cm high × 1.9 cm wide × 0.1 cm deep (about 15 × 19 × 1 mm). Measurements are taken at the widest points; please refer to the Measurements on this page for exact sizing.
Q: How do they fasten, and do they come with backs? A: They have sterling silver posts with friction (butterfly) backs for pierced ears. The pair includes backs; any additional items, such as a branded box, are listed under Accessories for this listing.
Q: Are they heavy to wear? A: No. As polished sterling silver studs with a slim profile, they are designed for comfortable, everyday wear. Comfort can vary by ear shape, but most customers find them light on the lobe.
Q: How should I clean and care for them? A: Gently polish with a non‑abrasive silver cloth and, if needed, use a small amount of silver jewellery cleaner. Rinse in warm water, dry thoroughly, and store in an anti‑tarnish pouch. Avoid chlorine, saltwater, harsh chemicals, or abrasive cleaners to minimise tarnish and preserve the finish.
Q: Can I wear them in the shower, swimming, or to sleep? A: We recommend removing sterling silver earrings before bathing, swimming, exercising, or sleeping to prevent accelerated tarnishing and to avoid bending the posts.
Q: Do hallmarks and proportions vary between authentic pairs? A: Yes. Genuine Return to Tiffany heart studs have changed slightly over the years and exist in different sizes. Authentic pieces typically carry crisp Tiffany & Co. and 925 marks; minor differences in placement or font can occur by production year and size.
Q: How does A Retro Tale authenticate this item? A: Every item is vetted by our in‑house experts using multi‑point checks of materials, finish, engraving, hallmarks, construction, and overall craftsmanship. We stand behind the authenticity of all items we sell and are happy to share additional photos or details on request.
SHIPPING
All orders are insured and trackable. Once your shipment has been issued, a link to our Track & Trace service will be provided where you can track your shipment and check delivery status online.
A Retro Tale offers free shipping to most EU countries. Click here to see the full list of eligible countries.
Outside EU, Åland and UK: Please note that customers outside of EU, Åland and UK are responsible upon delivery for any import duties, goods and services tax (GST), value added tax (VAT), customs fees, and any other tax on top of the A Retro Tale listed price. Delivery delays may occur due to external factors such as customs clearance, holidays etc.
We offer secure shipping via DHL and UPS with the following delivery time:
Europe: 1-4 business days.
Outside Europe: 3-6 business days.
AUTHENTICITY GUARANTEED
A Retro Tale specialises in vintage and pre-owned goods from the world's most loved fashion houses. We guarantee that all of our products are 100 percent authentic. Every item sold on our site undergoes a rigorous authentication process, in which our experts delve deep into the heritage of a brand via its craftsmanship techniques. This requires a rigorous and methodical process.
For us, authentication is about more than expertise; it offers a fascinating insight into the history of fashion and the craftsmanship involved in production.
Style discovery
If you have any questions about customs, duties, or taxes, feel free to contact our customer service team — we’re happy to help!
Height
Width
Depth
/ Tiffany & Co
/ Jewelry
/ Earrings
302 €
• Sterling silver
• Heart-shaped design
• 'Return to Tiffany' engraving
• Post back closure
• Vintage
Condition
Dimensions
Product Information
PRODUCT FAQ
Delivery & Returns
Authentication
Contact an expert
Recently viewed
1,5
cm
1.9
cm
0,1
cm
Verified authenticity by our experts
read more
Fast delivery, fully insured and traced
Free shipping & duty to EU, UK & NO
Delivered with
box
Made in
Italy
Product number:
859-35397
The authenticity of this piece of jewelry has been checked and certified by Kathrine, who has 20 years of experience in vintage and luxury jewelry.
